Roger Smith Insurance Agency
720 W. Market St., Tiffin, OH 44883
419-447-9900
419-447-9900
Roger Smith Insurance Agency
  • Get a Quote
  • Insurance Products
  • About Us
    • Our Team
    • Companies We Represent
    • Why an Independent Agent
    • Community Involvement/Charity
    • Referral Program
  • Client Services
    • Read This First Before Filing a Claim
    • Claims, Payments & Service
    • Free Account Review
  • Blog/FAQ
  • Testimonials

Client Services

  • Free Account Review
  • Read This First Before Filing a Claim

Get an Insurance Quote

Roger Smith Insurance Agency

Roger Smith Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency working for you by providing personal insurance, commercial insurance and employee benefits.

Insurance Products

  • Car Insurance
  • Home Insurance
  • Life Insurance
  • Individual/Family Health Insurance
  • Commercial/Business Insurance
  • Long Term Care Insurance
  • Disability Insurance
  • More

Important Links

  • Get a Quote
  • Insurance Products
  • About Us
  • Client Services
  • Blog/FAQ
  • Testimonials

Contact Us

720 W. Market St. · Tiffin, Ohio 44883
(419) 447-9900

Hours: M-F 8:30 am to 5:00 pm

© 2021 Roger Smith Insurance Agency · Terms of Service & Privacy Policy · Website by Link Software LLC Link Software LLC
custom logoOverall Satisfaction RatingOverall Satisfaction Rating
5 Stars - Based on 94 User Reviews
facebook logogoogle logologo
  • Amy Martinez AvatarAmy Martinez

    We recently had some issues with a wind storm , damage to our roof and vehicles , they made the whole process painless and got things with both insurances to... read moreWe recently had some issues with a wind storm , damage to our roof and vehicles , they made the whole process painless and got things with both insurances to get things taken care of . The staff was so nice and answered all my uestions and explained things to me so I knew how things would take place. I would highly recommend them for all your insurance needs !! read less - 3/10/2017 

    Facebook Logo
  • Joe Distel AvatarJoe Distel

    I can't say enough about Roger Smith insurance. They care for you like family! The whole team genuinely cares. Thank you for the honest advice you have given me, and... read moreI can't say enough about Roger Smith insurance. They care for you like family! The whole team genuinely cares. Thank you for the honest advice you have given me, and I will be a loyal customer for life! Roger Smith insurance A++ read less - 9/17/2016 

    Google Logo
  • Christopher Dannemiller AvatarChristopher Dannemiller

    We walked in to get quotes and and walked out with a new plan. Prices were better than we expected. Thanks - 9/17/2018 

    Google Logo
  • Cody Pachlhofer AvatarCody Pachlhofer

    Have had nothing but great experiences with Roger Smith! They help build a customer relationship unlike some companies and they help you find what's best for you. - 9/17/2018 

    Google Logo
  • Barb Kin AvatarBarb Kin

    I can actually talk to a person in person not just a voice on the phone. - 2/17/2019 

    Google Logo
  • Judi Travis AvatarJudi Travis

    Lindsey our Roger Smith agent is readily available to answer questions, quote , or change policy for me at any time. Very friendly ! I'm very happy to refer to... read moreLindsey our Roger Smith agent is readily available to answer questions, quote , or change policy for me at any time. Very friendly ! I'm very happy to refer to others because of the personalized service we have received. Thank you! read less - 9/17/2018 

    Google Logo
  • Sarah Babione AvatarSarah Babione

    Karen has been of great assistance to my family and I whether we have questions or concerns, she's there to help! Kyle's entire staff is very knowledgable and resourceful! - 9/17/2018 

    Google Logo
  • Venessa Runion AvatarVenessa Runion

    Very friendly staff and great rates - 11/22/2019 

    Facebook Logo
  • Ed Lamb AvatarEd Lamb

    Great customer service. Meet all your needs,. - 5/21/2020 

    Facebook Logo
  • Anthony Foster AvatarAnthony Foster

    I have been with Roger Smith since 2006 and have always been treated very well they are always helpful and easy to talk to! Always get great service from them. - 9/17/2018 

    Google Logo
  • Victoria Gamba AvatarVictoria Gamba

    Thank you for going all the way to review our insurance and Medicare needs. Excellent work and glad you are using an up-to-date software to price compare. - 11/19/2019 

    Facebook Logo
  • Autumn Knisely AvatarAutumn Knisely

    Lindsey is always willing to look around for the best rates and discounts and is there to answer any questions I may have. She's saved me a lot of money... read moreLindsey is always willing to look around for the best rates and discounts and is there to answer any questions I may have. She's saved me a lot of money over the past couple of years! read less - 10/17/2019 

    Google Logo
  • Travis Ardner AvatarTravis Ardner

    I’ve been in here twice for insurance for different things and they have treated me well and showed me everything with the policies! I even got a $5 gift card... read moreI’ve been in here twice for insurance for different things and they have treated me well and showed me everything with the policies! I even got a $5 gift card to Tim Horton’s! �� read less - 4/03/2018 

    Facebook Logo
  • Joe Marovich AvatarJoe Marovich

    Friendly service and good people. - 11/26/2019 

    Facebook Logo
  • Kelly Brickner AvatarKelly Brickner

    Roger Smith Insurance Agency staff is very personable with their clients, we felt they took the time to create our insurance policies with our individual needs in mind. We also... read moreRoger Smith Insurance Agency staff is very personable with their clients, we felt they took the time to create our insurance policies with our individual needs in mind. We also appreciate the informative emails. read less - 9/17/2017 

    Google Logo
  • Chris Magill AvatarChris Magill

    When we added our youngest son our insurance almost quadrupled with our current insurance provider who we were loyal to for several years. When I arrived at Roger Smith insurance... read moreWhen we added our youngest son our insurance almost quadrupled with our current insurance provider who we were loyal to for several years. When I arrived at Roger Smith insurance I expected more of the same but instead got first class treatment. Lindsey took the time to explain the coverages, how they lacked with my current plan and then quoted me a price that was unbelievable to me and my wife! And even after signing with them received several emails thanking us for our business and supplying us with multiple numbers in the event we have any questions or needs. Great place to do business with to say the least! read less - 9/17/2018 

    Google Logo
  • Tony Gase AvatarTony Gase

    Easy to work with and lowered my bill without losing any coverage. - 8/17/2017 

    Facebook Logo
  • Kathy Bradford AvatarKathy Bradford

    The service we received was excellent. Kyle didn't rush us but took all the time we needed to understand our options. No pressure. We liked that.
    Thanks - 3/03/2020 

    Facebook Logo
  • EJHarmon AvatarEJHarmon

    Lindsay and the others went out of their way to get us the best rate. Highly recommended!!! - 12/17/2017 

    Google Logo
  • chad dewald Avatarchad dewald

    Very easy to talk to and work with the staff. Got what I needed done and in a timely manner, for a great value - 9/17/2016 

    Google Logo
  • Nicki Reis AvatarNicki Reis

    Kyle Smith is great to work with. He is very patient and is willing to go the extra mile for you! Great Job! - 8/17/2019 

    Google Logo
  • Ashlee Phillips AvatarAshlee Phillips

    Betty helped me out this morning and was extremely polite and super helpful. Very pleasant to work with, thank you!! - 9/17/2018 

    Google Logo
  • Mark Tooley AvatarMark Tooley

    Roger Smith insurance always is looking out for the customers best interest, offers options and recommendations but always respects the customers opinions and decisions. - 9/17/2018 

    Google Logo
  • Debra Bean AvatarDebra Bean

    switched and saved $$$$. To the tune of $500 per year. - 10/23/2018 

    Facebook Logo
  • tiffintyler . Avatartiffintyler .

    Kyle and his team at Roger Smith have always been great at any time of need. Always polite and respectful and are the absolute best at getting you the... read moreKyle and his team at Roger Smith have always been great at any time of need. Always polite and respectful and are the absolute best at getting you the best insurance for any of your needs!! read less - 9/17/2018 

    Google Logo
  • Melissa Arnold AvatarMelissa Arnold

    We always have a great experience! Would definitely recommend doing business here. - 1/03/2020 

    Facebook Logo
  • Linda Hoerig AvatarLinda Hoerig

    Kyle helped me find the health care insurance that I was looking for. He answered every question I had and explained things I didn't understand. I appreciate the time... read moreKyle helped me find the health care insurance that I was looking for. He answered every question I had and explained things I didn't understand. I appreciate the time he took with me. read less - 11/03/2016 

    Facebook Logo
  • Nikki Harvey AvatarNikki Harvey

    Thanks for helping me today, Karen! Your explanation of my car insurance policy and willingness to help find a deal was very appreciated. - 9/13/2018 

    Facebook Logo
  • Michael Wittman AvatarMichael Wittman

    We appreciate the personal service we received to find the best plans to fit our requirements. Reviewing all our insurance plans and then making suggestions to update and increase... read moreWe appreciate the personal service we received to find the best plans to fit our requirements. Reviewing all our insurance plans and then making suggestions to update and increase coverage in an affordable way helped us move forward with greater peace of mind. read less - 1/15/2021 

    Facebook Logo
  • Michelle Kiser Clinger AvatarMichelle Kiser Clinger

    Very helpful and polite workers! Easy to talk to and just all around great customer service! - 9/27/2016 

    Facebook Logo
  • Trisha Meier AvatarTrisha Meier

    I really appreciate the personalized experience. I'm still figuring things out as far as insurance and such, and the whole team there has been very helpful... especially when I screw... read moreI really appreciate the personalized experience. I'm still figuring things out as far as insurance and such, and the whole team there has been very helpful... especially when I screw up. Which I appreciate. read less - 9/17/2017 

    Google Logo
  • cindy crispen Avatarcindy crispen

    Lindsey at Roger Smith Insurance in Tiffin, Oh had just rewrote our 2 autos/boat/home/rental property and saved us over $1500/yr. It was very easy and she had taken care... read moreLindsey at Roger Smith Insurance in Tiffin, Oh had just rewrote our 2 autos/boat/home/rental property and saved us over $1500/yr. It was very easy and she had taken care of our cancellations and sending new policies to our lenders. I would definitely recommend Lindsey Griffin to all my friends/family and associates with my line of business. Thank You Lindsey!! 5 Stars all the way :) read less - 12/10/2019 

    Google Logo
  • erika distel Avatarerika distel

    Very helpful and can answer any questions we had. Fast and reliable. - 9/17/2016 

    Google Logo
  • Kelly Moore AvatarKelly Moore

    They are very knowledgeable and personable. - 9/17/2018 

    Google Logo
  • Ruth Ellen Callihan AvatarRuth Ellen Callihan

    Lindsey was professional and proficient, knowledgable and kind. - 2/23/2017 

    Facebook Logo
  • Eric Lawson AvatarEric Lawson

    I have only dealt with Lindsey but I'm sure they are all just as helpful. She has always given me all my options and the values of each so... read moreI have only dealt with Lindsey but I'm sure they are all just as helpful. She has always given me all my options and the values of each so I can pick the best coverage for my budget. I'm very happy with everything they have done. read less - 9/17/2018 

    Google Logo
  • Trish Channels AvatarTrish Channels

    Being that I can be a terribly flaky client, the Roger Smith staff - no matter whom I get on the phone - goes far beyond the norm to accommodate... read moreBeing that I can be a terribly flaky client, the Roger Smith staff - no matter whom I get on the phone - goes far beyond the norm to accommodate and fix my errors. Specifically Betty, she is phenomenal. I am sure she might cringe at times seeing my emails, but that woman works hard to always make us happy and to ultimately save my family money. We have absolutely no intention of ever switching companies. Your customer service is stellar! read less - 11/14/2017 

    Facebook Logo
  • Melonie Rapp AvatarMelonie Rapp

    I do not contact the office that often but when I do the staff is instantly available. Karen is my "go to" agent. She always makes time for... read moreI do not contact the office that often but when I do the staff is instantly available. Karen is my "go to" agent. She always makes time for my questions . Also, she will contact me when she sees rates increasing and provides options for a lesser rate if possible. read less - 10/01/2016 

    Facebook Logo
  • Doug Bouillon AvatarDoug Bouillon

    I was impressed that they periodically review their customers current policies and share savings opportunities. I never had that before. - 5/02/2017 

    Facebook Logo
  • Michelle Clinger AvatarMichelle Clinger

    Very helpful and polite workers! Easy to talk to and just all around great customer service! - 9/17/2016 

    Google Logo
  • Greg Ranker AvatarGreg Ranker

    They are very knowledgeable and give great customer Service - 2/15/2019 

    Facebook Logo
  • heather oesch Avatarheather oesch

    This company has always been great to work with. Every time I email Lindsay she responds to me within minutes. Great customer service! - 2/17/2019 

    Google Logo
  • Derrick Rhodes AvatarDerrick Rhodes

    It’s like cheers when you walk into the office... everyone knows your name. Always willing to help when it is needed. Community oriented. Prices are always great. - 9/17/2018 

    Google Logo
  • Melissa Boes AvatarMelissa Boes

    Thanks to Karen, we were able to save a lot of money. It was a wonderful experience. - 5/17/2019 

    Google Logo
  • Sarah Burkholder-Porter AvatarSarah Burkholder-Porter

    We have been satisfied with the service we have received and everyone in the office is very friendly and helpful. I would definitely recommend you to anyone looking to compare... read moreWe have been satisfied with the service we have received and everyone in the office is very friendly and helpful. I would definitely recommend you to anyone looking to compare policies and try to save money. read less - 9/26/2016 

    Facebook Logo
  • Brandon Glick AvatarBrandon Glick

    Easy to work with! I lowered my premium and improved my coverage! - 9/17/2018 

    Google Logo
  • Devin Frank AvatarDevin Frank

    Barb listened to my concerns and found me the right insurance package for my new home. I really appreciated her timely communication and working with all parties throughout the... read moreBarb listened to my concerns and found me the right insurance package for my new home. I really appreciated her timely communication and working with all parties throughout the home buying process. read less - 12/17/2018 

    Google Logo
  • Allison Stevens AvatarAllison Stevens

    This is my first plan as I recently switched off of my parent's insurance. The staff at Roger Smith insurance made it an easy transition and were very informative and... read moreThis is my first plan as I recently switched off of my parent's insurance. The staff at Roger Smith insurance made it an easy transition and were very informative and helpful every step of the way! read less - 9/17/2017 

    Google Logo
  • tiffintyler Avatartiffintyler

    Kyle and his team at Roger Smith have always been great at any time of need. Always polite and respectful and are the absolute best at getting you the... read moreKyle and his team at Roger Smith have always been great at any time of need. Always polite and respectful and are the absolute best at getting you the best insurance for any of your needs!! read less - 12/17/2017 

    Google Logo
  • Sarah Wonderly AvatarSarah Wonderly

    We are beyond happy with Roger Smith Insurance Co! We are now saving over $1,200 a year AND we have better coverage! Who wouldn't love that?! The immediate savings has... read moreWe are beyond happy with Roger Smith Insurance Co! We are now saving over $1,200 a year AND we have better coverage! Who wouldn't love that?! The immediate savings has already helped us put more money in our pockets. Working with Roger Smith has been a breeze and our agent, Lindsey, was so helpful through the whole process.

    Thank you!!!
    read less - 7/13/2018 

    Facebook Logo
  • Simone Lang AvatarSimone Lang

    Always ready and helpful! - 10/17/2019 

    Google Logo
  • Joya Ann AvatarJoya Ann

    Very helpful. Gets the best rates for your insuance needs. - 9/10/2019 

    Facebook Logo
  • Carol Jurrus AvatarCarol Jurrus

    Lindsey is our go to agent. She has always saved us alot of money on our coverage!
    Very polite and professional. - 8/28/2018 

    Facebook Logo
  • EJHarmon . AvatarEJHarmon .

    Lindsay and the others went out of their way to get us the best rate. Highly recommended!!! - 9/17/2017 

    Google Logo
  • Katina Brown AvatarKatina Brown

    Kyle was very thorough with the teaching aspect of our insurance and Saved us money!! - 3/17/2015 

    Facebook Logo
  • Patrick Huffman AvatarPatrick Huffman

    Roger Smith Insurance saved me enough on auto insurance to cover my individual health insurance premium. Not only that, they did so at nearly four time the coverage than my... read moreRoger Smith Insurance saved me enough on auto insurance to cover my individual health insurance premium. Not only that, they did so at nearly four time the coverage than my previous Allstate agent.
    Unbelievable feeling knowing that they are working in MY best interest and they've likely gained a lifetime customer.
    I simply can't thank them enough for the piece of mind that they've provided.
    read less - 10/15/2020 

    Facebook Logo
  • Joyce Brown AvatarJoyce Brown

    Kyle has really helped us find the best investments to help us. And he helped me to begin my retirement. - 7/17/2019 

    Google Logo
  • Nichole Reis AvatarNichole Reis

    great people to work with. - 8/01/2019 

    Facebook Logo
  • J David Wheeler AvatarJ David Wheeler

    Thanks to Lindsey for the homeowners and auto quote and saving me some jack !!!!!!!!!! - 3/13/2018 

    Facebook Logo
  • Beverly Ann Hemmerly AvatarBeverly Ann Hemmerly

    Always friendly and courteous staff. Prompt responses when I call them. Karen Brose goes above and beyond. - 12/27/2018 

    Facebook Logo
  • Maria Anderson AvatarMaria Anderson

    You made the process incredibly easy and fast. You got back to us right away when we called for information. We have already recommended you to a couple of people... read moreYou made the process incredibly easy and fast. You got back to us right away when we called for information. We have already recommended you to a couple of people because we were so impressed with the service and the savings!Thank you! read less - 9/17/2017 

    Google Logo
  • melissa m Avatarmelissa m

    I really appreciate how fast Kyle got back to me when I inquired about a home insurance quote. He was very friendly and professional. I also appreciate how he was... read moreI really appreciate how fast Kyle got back to me when I inquired about a home insurance quote. He was very friendly and professional. I also appreciate how he was able to bundle my home and auto insurance read less - 12/03/2019 

    Google Logo
  • Alisha Goshe AvatarAlisha Goshe

    Roger Smith Insurance cut both our home and auto insurance rates in half, and increased our coverage at the same time. We are so glad we made the switch! Kyle... read moreRoger Smith Insurance cut both our home and auto insurance rates in half, and increased our coverage at the same time. We are so glad we made the switch! Kyle is personable and made shopping for insurance very easy! read less - 9/17/2016 

    Google Logo
  • Brian Wright AvatarBrian Wright

    Never a problem. Always get prompt accurate replies to my questions or issues no matter how small or insignificant. - 9/17/2017 

    Google Logo
  • Mary Cook AvatarMary Cook

    Very, very helpful staff. Explains things very clearly. Very friendly. - 9/17/2018 

    Google Logo
  • Nancy Hurley AvatarNancy Hurley

    Whenever we had a question about our policies Kyle or his staff have always gotten back to us quickly with an answer. The staff is helpful and courteous. - 9/17/2016 

    Google Logo
  • Marcus Conti AvatarMarcus Conti

    Lindsey found us the best auto and home policy that fit our needs for the best price.Lindsey was able to save us about $800 from my previous agent with better... read moreLindsey found us the best auto and home policy that fit our needs for the best price.Lindsey was able to save us about $800 from my previous agent with better coverage. She was also able to find a policy that included roadside assistance which my previous auto coverage policy did not offer. Lindsey was very professional and friendly. read less - 8/17/2019 

    Google Logo
  • Sarah Wonderly AvatarSarah Wonderly

    We are beyond happy with Roger Smith Insurance Co! We are now saving over $1,200 a year AND we have better coverage! Who wouldn't love that?! The immediate savings has... read moreWe are beyond happy with Roger Smith Insurance Co! We are now saving over $1,200 a year AND we have better coverage! Who wouldn't love that?! The immediate savings has already helped us put more money in our pockets. Working with Roger Smith has been a breeze and our agent, Lindsey, was so helpful through the whole process. Thank you!!! read less - 9/17/2018 

    Google Logo
  • Ann Zablocki Huth-Fretz AvatarAnn Zablocki Huth-Fretz

    Worked with Karen Brose this morning on a new build and she had everything within a few hours! Easy to work with. 💕 - 4/14/2020 

    Facebook Logo
  • Charita Hartman AvatarCharita Hartman

    Very prompt and friendly service :) - 4/17/2019 

    Google Logo
  • Kari Bottoms AvatarKari Bottoms

    We recently moved to Tiffin and in the process of purchasing a home needed a home insurance quote quick. I completed an inquiry online one night and early the... read moreWe recently moved to Tiffin and in the process of purchasing a home needed a home insurance quote quick. I completed an inquiry online one night and early the next morning I was messaged by Lindsey following up on my quote. I also received several messages from Kyle Smith and have had many pleasant interactions with both. The quotes I received had lower premiums for more coverage than we have had with previous companies. The customer service is amazing they really seem to care, which I love in a day and time when that often seems so rare. read less - 7/17/2019 

    Google Logo
  • Jackie Therriault AvatarJackie Therriault

    They are willing to take the time to find the best for you and willing to take the time to answer your questionns - 4/08/2019 

    Facebook Logo
  • Nicki Smith AvatarNicki Smith

    Great people, great service - 8/09/2019 

    Facebook Logo
  • Tyler Matthew Brown AvatarTyler Matthew Brown

    Always taken care of anything we need and more! Always able to get us in for appointments quickly and wonderful staff! Kyle is great! - 8/29/2018 

    Facebook Logo